Chapter 19
Having finally gotten a quiet moment alone with Lucifer, it seemed like the perfect opportunity to get to the bottom of some things that had been troubling Alastor for some time. “Tell me something, Lucifer, as our so-called King of Hell and the very embodiment of Pride, why do you insist on ignoring all of Hell?”
Lucifer had come around from behind the bar to join Alastor in simply sitting and having some coffee, which he had brewed nice and fresh and perfect. He had hoped for just a comfortable quiet, maybe even a cordial moment with The Radio Demon. If he was going to have to suffer having Alastor as his ‘knight’ for the foreseeable future, he wanted them to at least be capable of civil interactions and perhaps even pleasant conversations over coffee like two colleges. Apparently, Alastor had other plans. Lucifer sighed, “can we not just sit here and drink our coffee peacefully? Why are you trying to provoke me?”
“Who said I was trying to provoke you? I simply asked a perfectly reasonable question.”
“Well, it’s not ‘perfectly reasonable’ to me, okay? It’s…complicated. And anyway what do you care?”
“Hmmm I am merely trying to sketch the nature of your character, but I don’t get on at all. I both observe and hear such contradictory accounts of you as to puzzle me exceedingly.”
“Sketch my character? As in determine what sort of person I am? Seriously, Bellhop, who even speaks that way anymore? As for analyzing me, don’t. I would really prefer if you didn’t attempt to ‘sketch my character’, as you put it.”
“Oh, but if I don’t capture your likeness now, I may never get another chance.”
Lucifer rolled his eyes and scuffed, “I wouldn’t dream of denying any pleasure of yours, Bambi.”
“Splendid! Then you won’t mind answering my questions and helping me to gain a better illustration you.”
“Why are you trying to understand me? It’s not like you’re even interested in me. Did Lily put you up to this? Or is this like, one of Charlie’s trust exercises?”
“Heavens no! I would never partake in such whacky nonsense and misguided means to try to force camaraderie.”
“Hey! That’s my daughter you’re talking about! Sure Charlie’s methods are…uhm…something…no, uh, what I mean is…unconventional! Yeah, that’s the word! They’re just, unconventional, but it seems like they’re working, I guess, I mean she did actually get a guy redeemed, so what do we know?” Lucifer had lost his enthusiasm mid ramble and by the end he once again trailed off into his own thoughts.
Alastor noticed his coffee companion’s mental retreat. “Feeling guilty about doubting Charlie’s little redemption project? Or are you perhaps comparing her success with your own failed efforts?”
“Are you implying that I would be jealous of MY OWN DAUGHTER?”
“Temper temper, Lucifer. I have at least ascertained enough about your character not to imply that you would envy your daughter, though perhaps your pride might be wounded enough in the wake of her success as to believe yourself to be inadequate? However, regardless of how prideful, snobbish, and selfish you may be, you have demonstrated an obnoxiously sentimental devotion to your child. You are far more forgiving of her than you are to yourself it seems. I was merely concerned that your pathetic self-loathing may have distracted you from our conversation.”
“Self-loathing? I’m one of the most powerful beings in creation. I’m practically a god. What makes you think I’d have any reason to loath myself?” Lucifer didn’t miss Alastor poorly obscured backhanded compliments, but he was of no mind to decipher his thoughts and feelings on any of that at the moment.
“You’re not a failure, Lucifer.”
“Uh…what? I never said I was. I’m pretty sure I literally just said the opposite.”
“You were thinking it. In fact, I’m pretty sure you’ve been thinking it for some time. Don’t you think it’s about time you got over it and started behaving more like the divine being you claim to be?”
“Weeeelllll first of all, fuck you. Second, who the hell do you think you are? Didn’t I just tell you not to try and ‘sketch my character’?” Alastor couldn’t really expect him to believe he was trying to get to know him? Alastor is a demon. As such, he was probably just digging for information to potentially use against him.
“Whenever I try to have a meaningful conversation with you, you deflect and somehow manage to turn everything into an argument. Sometimes, Lucifer, a conversation really is meant to be just that.” Alastor stood to leave. ‘What was I expecting? Of course this prideful prick wouldn’t even see fit to humor me. Why should the Morningstar give consequence to mortal souls slighted by both Heaven and the ranking classes of Hellborn?’ Before he could dissolve into his shadows a hand shot out and grabbed his wrist.
“Wait. I’m not trying to start a fight.” Lucifer sighed for the umpteenth time. “I may be trying to avoid the conversation, though. It’s not the company, it’s the topic.”
Alastor stared at Lucifer, who hadn’t removed his hand from Alastor’s wrist yet. The King didn’t even look up to match his stare. He kept his gaze down as though he were looking for answers in the bottom of his coffee mug. “Hmmm.” Alastor sat back down.
Lucifer released the wrist he’d been holding. “It’s just not easy for me to have meaningful conversations. I couldn’t even talk to Lily.”
“Why would a being such as yourself, who has existed across the expanse of time and space, accumulated unimaginable knowledge, and is known to be a dreamer with all sorts of ideas want to avoid conversation? It’s an opportunity to share your acquired wisdom and your whimsy with others. One would think the Sin of Pride would relish the chance to show off and to boast of his greatness.”
“Mocking me isn’t the best way to prevent an argument here, Pal.” Although that last bit was clearly Alastor trying to prod him into banter, Lucifer noticed the complements that preceded it hadn’t been backhanded this time. “I thought you wanted a conversation.”
“Oh, trust me, if I were mocking you, I could do so much better than that. I meant what I said. I don’t understand why you avoid telling your side of things. Why does it seem like you’re omitting your perspectives?”
“Because no one listens! No one cares! I tried, Alastor, I tried so many times. What’s the point? My perspectives are just…too much. Even if I did answer your questions, you’ve already formed your own opinion anyway, haven’t you? Why would you believe anything I say? I’m just ‘The Father of Lies’ and ‘The Devil’. Why would you, or anyone, listen to me? Isn’t that what got all you sinners dropped down here? Listening to The Devil? The Devil made you do it, right?”
“Oh nonsense. As if you could make me do anything I didn’t want to. Ha! No.”
“Even so, I can’t exactly…recommend my ideas or opinions to others. I don’t have…I’m ill-qualified to even recommend myself to others.”
“Why? Tell me, Lucifer, why should the Morningstar, the most precious of God’s angels, the advisor to God himself, be ill-qualified to recommend himself to others? If anything, shouldn’t such a being be held in high esteem? Shouldn’t it be considered an honor to converse with a being such as yourself? Or even to just be in your presence? Why allow yourself to be so scorned?”
“Hold up. Didn’t you scorn me the last time we attempted to have a conversation? Didn’t you say something about me being to conceited and uncivil to everyone at the hotel when Charlie introduced them to me? Now you’re telling me I SHOULD be a jerk?”
“You can hold yourself in esteem without being an uncivil prideful prick. All I’m saying is that where there is a superiority of mind, pride will always be under good regulation. Before I was saying you should recognize the value in those worthy and not think yourself so far above them. Now I am saying you should also not think yourself beneath anyone. No one is without faults, not even you. During that last conversation I believe I recall you saying your good opinion once lost is lost forever. Does that sentiment also apply to yourself? Have you truly no capacity to forgive even yourself?”
“I condemned all of mankind! Everything is my fault. I gave humans free will and look what they did with it! I corrupted them by allowing evil into their realm. You can’t be blind to all the depravity around here no matter how entertaining you find it.”
“Certainly, but that’s not anything YOU did, is it? These sinners made their own choices. All you did was gift them the ability to make choices. Besides, not all human souls became sinners. What about the winners? You only ever get to see the most awful souls humanity has to offer and the consequences of their free will. Have you ever considered what your gift of free will, not to mention your other gifts of fire, science, math, art, and music might have done for those souls who became winners? Why only blame yourself for those who find their way here? Why not also credit yourself for those who make it to heaven? Sin of Pride, indeed. As if you had anything to do with where a soul ends up. No no, dear. All you did was give these souls the means. They did the rest all on their own.”
Lucifer stared directly into Alastor’s eyes for the first time since his near spiral into his coffee cup. There was no deception. It seemed Alastor did mean what he was saying. No hint of mocking. Just…‘admiration? Appreciation?’ Lucifer couldn’t tell, ‘but it’s something that started with an A’. That something was shining in Alastor’s eyes. The way those eyes were looking at Lucifer, well, if Lucifer thought Alastor’s eyes were …another something earlier that evening, they were even more of that…something now. “I’m the most hated being in all of creation.”
“Also the most loved.”
Lucifer choked and started coughing but he managed to wheeze out a strangled, “pardon?”
“Were you not God’s most beloved? Are you not still worshiped by so many on Earth and even praised as the most beautiful being in all creation? The First Temptation? I thought that was the very reason for your pride.”
“I…well yes, but, I mean that was a long time ago.”
Alastor shrugged. “Some things are timeless. You of all people should know that.”
Lucifer stared in bewilderment as Alastor refilled their mugs with fresh hot coffee. Good thing too because Lucifer was definitely going to need more of that coffee to process whatever that conversation just was. “I still don’t see any reason to impart my views. I don’t need to answer your questions just to satisfy your curiosity.” ‘Because that’s all this was, right? Alastor was just curious’. Lucifer had noticed that The Radio Demon did seem to be an intellectual sort with a bit more wit about him than most sinners. He supposed it was only natural that after all this time in Hell an inquisitive mind would grow curious.
“Then don’t.”
“Uh, what now?”
“Don’t answer my questions. Actually, I think I prefer you didn’t. I much rather you listen and determine for yourself if the picture I managed to render of you all on my own is to your likeness. I can gauge my accuracy based on your reactions.”
“You really think you’ve got me all figured out, don’t you? Alright, let’s have it then, Mr. Know It All.”
“Very well. I think you’ve forgotten who you are. I think you’ve been trapped here for far too long under the very wrong opinions of others such that you’ve been brain washed into thinking YOU’RE the problem. They’ve all got you convinced that you failed, you messed up, you did something wrong, you can’t be loved when none of that is true. These are just opinions, Lucifer, and very wrong ones at that. Just because the majority, or even if everyone, believes something, that doesn’t make it true. If anything, it might make it a case of mass delusion and ignorance. I believe you suppress yourself, lessen yourself in order to make others happy. You stifle yourself and dim your own light because you don’t want to outshine your wife and daughter.”
“Ex-wife,” Lucifer mumbled.
Alastor continued, “You make yourself miserable for the sake of others’ happiness. You take all the blame and burdens upon yourself because you’ve been made to believe you deserve to be punished. The only thing I can’t understand is how you still believe you were the one in the wrong. I know you understand the concept of consent, the value of souls, and the joy of living freely. Those were all heavenly concepts, were they not? All you did was enable humans to enjoy those same concepts by freeing us from the constraints and demands cruelly placed upon the first humans by Heaven. I’m sure both our perceptive former queen and our compassionate princess have told you themselves that you did nothing wrong. The reason you cannot see it is because you don’t believe them.”
“Hey! I never said that! I…of course I believe them…or at least I believe they don’t think I did it on purpose. It’s just, that’s the thing, I DID do it on purpose and I …,” Lucifer bit his lip. He shouldn’t be saying any of this, but Alastor had been so painfully right and Lucifer had been woefully unprepared for it. He didn’t even know what he was thinking or feeling. Lucifer hadn’t known for years because he’d been swallowing it down and ignoring it all while telling himself he should just do what he can to make up for everything and give Lilith and Charlie as good of life as they could hope to have in Hell. To think Alastor would bulldoze right past his emotional walls and rip off the chains holding his very broken heart together.
“You what, Lucifer?”
“I’m not sorry.”
“Why should you be?”
“I condemned everyone. I created this place. I defied Heaven and corrupted humanity because I wanted to, for my own beliefs, my own ideas…and I’m not sorry. I still think this is better. In fact, I’d do it all again.”
“As you should.”
“I’m serious, Alastor.”
“So am I.”
“I still think Heaven is wrong. They never listen, and when I tried to show them, this was their verdict. Don’t you think they had other options?”
“Oh, I’m sure they did.”
“Exactly! They chose this! To punish me! Just because they were angry with me and couldn’t control me, they allowed all of humanity to suffer the consequences with me. They could have stopped the corruption, but they chose to punish me instead, and Lily, who was completely innocent! Heaven did this! On purpose!”
“So why are you the one still carrying the guilt?”
“What?”
“Why are you letting yourself be punished? Why are you taking the blame? Why are you letting your daughter believe that YOU need to be redeemed? It’s one thing for her to want to correct the mistakes sinners made, but you made no mistake. There’s nothing for you to hide yourself away from. Why not let yourself be seen and be valued? You’re the ring master of this infernal circus, aren’t you? Why not give us all a real show?”
“I bet you’d find that entertaining.” Lucifer, now much calmer, smirked up mischievously at Alastor. It felt like an eon’s worth of weight had been lifted from him, all thanks to Alastor being his annoyingly persistent self. There was also still something in the way that Alastor continued to look at him. Lucifer was only just realizing what that something resembled, but it couldn’t possibly be the A word he thought it was. Maybe it was just the mood of the night, or the swirling cacophony of emotions Lucifer was feeling playing tricks on him. Could the something in Alastor’s eyes really be not admiration or appreciation, but adoration? Had Alastor always looked at him that way?

Leave a Reply